I had the good fortune, this past weekend, to head down to New York City ever so briefly for a performance of this play. I am working under a new operating code that encourages occasional trips to the city for single, isolated cultural events - a play, an opera - that I’m just not going to experience here. So, I was actually in New York City for about 8 hours, during which time, in addition to the play, I made it to Zabar’s, Kossar’s Bialy, the Pickle Guys, and a great Jewish cafe on the lower East Side (I ordered 1 gefilte fish and split pea soup w/ hot sauce - probably not a standard combo). In any case, I’m back in Maine now, and have over the past couple of days been enjoying the spoils of my conquest. I used to do this kind of stocking up all the time when I first moved here, but gradually I began to accept the quality of the local bagels and smoked salmon as, if not definitive, at least a worthy facsimile of the real thing. And it’s true, bagels in Portland, Maine are actually kind of decent - as good as your randomly selected bagel on the street in Manhattan perhaps (but no contenders with the upper echelon bagels of Absolute, Ess-a-Bagel, even H&H (that clip joint). But when it comes to salmon, despite its ubiquitousness here, there’s just no competition. David - the fish cutting genius at Zabars who used to have a pony tail - is without equal, and the difference between fresh cut and pre-sliced packaged salmon is something akin to the difference between the fresh baked morning muffin and the sadly Glad-wrapped afternoon remainder. Anyway, I stocked up and am happy, but supplies are already dwindling.
I achieved my bagel and spread expertise as a child - each Sunday my family would have the most decadent of brunches. Bagels, lox, spreads of every color and consistency (just about all of them involving some sort of smoked fish), herring in cream sauce, baked salmon, the occasional whitefish or sturgeon. I just never understood how good I had it - at all. Oh to be teleported back in time to just one of those Sunday meals, Vivaldi playing on the living room stereo, the Sunday Times sprawled messily amidst the crumbs and spreads and coffees - not to mention the four of us family folk. Just one hour back at that transcendent point in space and time. Here’s some of what I’m left with:
1. A good fresh bagel should never be toasted. The whole point of a hand rolled and dense bagel is its chew. Perhaps a light crunch on the outside, but a voluptuous chewiness that melds with whatever you’ve spread into one paradisaical, globulous orgy of taste and texture. To toast a bagel is to strip it of its fundamental raison d’etre, to reduce it to mere “toast,” that workaday staple. A poor, out-of-state bagel may be toasted only to hide its inferiority. A good one, if truly fresh, should remain unmolested by contemporary heating technologies once it leaves the oven. OR, you may place the whole bagel, uncut, in an oven at about 300F, and wait a little while. The goal here is to bring the bagel back - as closely as is possible - to its original, post-baking state. A light crunch on the outside, and a world of heavenly steam upon the first slice - this is the mark of a properly and lovingly reheated bagel. The world is deeply mixed up about this.
2. I won’t make judgments about variety here. I’m not actually a purist - for a while I liked the jalapeno bagels at Lenny’s on the Upper West Side, until I realized they always gave me a stomachache. Recently my sister turned me on to egg Bagels - which have a hint of challah to them. Sun dried tomato bagels strike me as wrong-headed, but I’ve seen worse and who am I to decide? Pumpernickels are essential. I sympathize with salt bagel fans, though I don’t count myself among their number. Everything bagels are delicious, onion bagels daring, and garlic bagels have to them such a devil-may-care attitude they demand your love. Cinnamon raisin bagels are sublime but inconvenient - they’re no partner to the essential chive cream cheese, for instance - but a good walnut raisin shmear sends these to the stratosphere. Sesame and poppy bagels are proletariat - they don’t excite me, but I’m not fool enough to deny their rightful place on this earth, and also their honorable adaptability. Whole wheat, multigrain, and rye bagels all can be quite splendid. But blueberry bagels are ridiculous.
3. As for spreads: when my sister and I were kids, we maintained that the proper way to eat a Sunday brunch bagel was to gather every possible ingredient on the table within the loving clasp of a single steaming bagel, seal it up, and devour the cacophonous, unholy (literally) wreck. We knew, however, that this was really just a caprice of youth, and enjoyed it while it lasted. As an adult I know that every flavor, combined = vanilla. (As an aside, I can prove this: when I was 14 and had a job at Baskin Robbins (my first), as an experiment I spearheaded an effort to make an “everything shake.” That’s right, using a taster spoon we make a shake that had all 40 or so flavors (31 was just the minimum), and a little bit of all four or five syrups. We blended it up and I swear to you it tasted just like vanilla - I’m not making this stuff up.)
Now I’m an adult and I know better. I know that each spread should be afforded its own special bagel real estate - though occasional combinations are acceptable. The obvious one is shmear (New York deli-language for cream cheese) and lox - and the best flavor of cream cheese for this is chive (when a deli man tells you that chive and scallion cream cheese are the same, that deli man is a fool). Otherwise, I like these:
Whitefish spread (or salad): When I first moved to Portland I walked into Mr. Bagel and asked for a bagel sandwich w/ whitefish salad, lettuce and tomato. I was met with utter speechlessness - the thing doesn’t exist up here. It’s all over in New York, though it can often be too mayonnaisy and runny and gross. At its best, it has a thick, solidish consistency and tastes deeply of the sea (but a sea engulfed in smoke). I can live with or without celery in this. The Zabars version, which I just picked up, is simple - no celery - and maybe the best I’ve ever tasted.
Chopped herring - I’m not sure but you may have to be either a) Jewish or b) Eastern European to stomach this stuff. It tends to be sweet rather than salty, and there’s no sugar-coating it, it looks godawful. I love it. I think Philip Roth mentions it in a late scene in Operation Shylock that takes place at Barney Greengrass on Amsterdam Avenue (I can’t recall if the cafe is explicitly identified as such).
Herring and onions in cream sauce (or wine sauce): This exists in jars up here from various companies. But it is never remotely as good as the fresh item from Zabars or Russ and Daughter or some such place. Even at its best, herring has a slightly vulgar, slightly sexual quality. The jarred varietals, alas, have added to this an element of skank. I’ll tolerate the skank when depserate, but there’s no comparison with a fresh helping of the real mccoy. The goopy, heart clogging cream sauce and generous chunks of succulent, toothsome fish, ornamented by crisp circles of sliced onions and just the right balance of sweetness is an aphrodisiac if ever there was one. This may, in fact, be my favorite food on the planet. Lately I skip the bagel for this stuff and snarf it right out of the plastic container. My mom never liked the herring much - she just wanted the onions in the herring cream sauce. So I may not have come to this love until later in life.
Whitefish (and other baked fishes) - The whole whitefish, as opposed to the chopped-in-a-salad version, has a historical and humorous place in my family’s lore (and one which I’ve blogged about before). In short, this is what you bring to people sitting shiva (a Jewish ritual of opening the house - and filling it with food - for a week after the death of a loved one). When my dad died - forever changing our Sunday bagel ritual - we had a freezer full of whitefish. Hence, this is a rather mournful food for me - but one which I enjoy nonetheless. Baked salmon is nice too, and so is baked sturgeon though I don’t get why it’s so expensive. Somehow smoked trout seems to fit in here too - though we never had it when I was a kid.
Tomatoes - I’ve been confused my whole life about whether tomatoes belong on a bagel with cream cheese and lox. Ultimately I have to lean in the direction of no they don’t - though I’ve often been a violator of this dictum. Do you know what tomatoes were put on this earth for? I mean, do you really want to see a raw, sliced tomato do its splendiforous thing? Okay listen closely: Haloumi sandwich. Haloumi is a hard, salty cypriot cheese that generally is either grilled or fried (it isn’t much good raw). A warm pita, some fried up Haloumi, and a few fat slices of tomato and you’ll understand all at once what God was thinking. The cheese is almost inedibly salty without the juicy, salt-absorbing balm of the tomato. (You can get Haloumi in Astoria for cheap, or, if you’re in Maine, you can pay the insane price of $6.99 for a block of it - it’s worth the very occasional splurge). But I don’t think tomato works quite right in the bagel situation, unless, I suppose, you’ve got some extra salty lox. The whole mess of it just gets watered down, you know? (For a while I enjoyed this bagel attrocity: bagel, toasted (I know, I know), with sliced tomatoes and hot sauce and that’s it. That was my definition of something healthy. Actually, this yields a revelation - a tomato is too wet for an untoasted bagel - the dough just turns to mush. So here’s an argument for the toasted bagel, but one that is clearly limited in scope).
I feel as though I’ve had my say for today. I hope this proves helpful to at least one of you.